Sign in: Staff/Students
Alexandra Woods is a PhD candidate in the University of Liverpool’s Department of Politics
“I graduated from the University of Liverpool in 2009 with a BA (Hons) in History and Politics, and after working in accountancy for several years returned to undertake an MA in International Relations & Security. It was whilst studying for my MA that I became interested in the work being done within IR studies on human trafficking, and was fortunate to be able to commence a PhD with Dr Alex Balch, an expert in human trafficking, as my supervisor.
Having always been particularly interested in human rights, women’s studies and international development, I developed a particular focus for my research looking at the ways we think and talk about people who have been trafficked, and the effect that this has on their human rights.
For example, the traditional focus in the study of human trafficking has been on the trafficking of women for sex work, in spite of the fact that estimates show that more trafficking is for forced labour, and a significant percentage of victims are male.
Why is it then that so much of the awareness of human trafficking has focused on female victims of sex trafficking? Superficially, of course the media are always going to focus on stories that are more lurid and photogenic, but on a deeper level, do we find it easier to accept a young, female victim than a middle aged male one? To add another layer, do we find it easier to accept a simple narrative of the young girl stolen from the street than a more complicated scenario were the fine line between consent and coercion has to be considered?
Many of those who are trafficked have agreed to involvement with their trafficker, be it to be smuggled across a border that they could not legally cross, work in a factory or for sex work. However at some point the situation became exploitative, and for it to be considered trafficking the person has to be in some way held against their will, within the exploitative situation. There are problems even with this definition of trafficking, as the term is often co-opted for political reasons relating to migration.
The research aims to demonstrate a more nuanced picture of human trafficking. The findings could have significant impact if we are to drastically improve the way we attempt to combat it. Rather than treating human trafficking exclusively as an international organised crime issue, it could also become one more properly relating to migration and labour rights.
This leads on to the other key issue I am trying to address within my research, which is the relationship between prostitution and human trafficking. Different factions exist that think of prostitution in very different ways, some believing it to be inherently exploitative and a degradation of women, therefore making all prostitution a form of trafficking, others believing it to be a legitimate form of work.
This has been in the news recently with Amnesty International proposals to officially back the decriminalisation of sex work internationally, and the response condemning this by the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women (CATW) supported by several A-list celebrities. The side of the debate one falls on determines the way in which trafficking is combatted, as it changes the perspective on who is a trafficking victim.
By investigating these issues, it is hoped that we can inform debates and lead to constructive change in the fight to combat human trafficking.”
You must be logged in to post a comment.
All recent news
Free access to fiction, film, magazines and non-fiction books
UK elections 2021: your complete guide to the May 6 votes
Update on reorganisation of Faculty of Health and Life Sciences
Summer Term Events Programme – What’s on during week 4
Update: Greenbank COVID-19 testing site
Our paper on immune responses to COVID vaccine (mostly Pfizer) in 237 healthcare workers, 124 #SARSCoV2 naïve and 113 previously infected, from the PITCH consortium @pitchstudy is out as a pre-print today.
See if you can spot us in the new @NetflixUK series, The Irregulars! 📽️
Our @VictoriaGallery appears in it, as well as other locations across the city including St George’s Plateau, the Palm House in Sefton Park and Falkner Street in the Georgian Quarter.
Professor Michael Parkinson CBE, author of 1985's Liverpool on the Brink, and Liverpool Beyond the Brink in 2019, analyses the Caller Report, the Gov's Best Value inspection into Liverpool City Council